Some may ask how I can use AI to help me develop this site when they believe AI constitutes wholesale theft of copyrighted works.
If the artists were paid for the rental or purchase of a work used in training data and the output of the trained LLM is not so similar to their specific works as to constitute infringement, then it’s fair use. Please note this statement is my personal opinion and is not, at the time of this writing, settled law. Should SCOTUS rule that it is not fair use, I will accept their wisdom and proceed in accordance with the new legal standard.
We had a chance to have this decided, but the authors chose to accept a $1.5 billion settlement with Anthropic. It would have taken both sides years of appeals to get it to SCOTUS, but other suits continue.
Still, I’m not reproducing the works of Sir Terry Pratchett, but he’s sure as hell firmly lodged in my brain’s training data. I bought most of the books, borrowed a few.
The point at which we turn toward an egalitarian Star Trek utopia or a Blade Runner or Snow Crash dystopia will be upon us soon, if it is not already. I believe a lot of AI hate comes from the belief that the 1% will force us down the dystopian path. We’ll have mass poverty, ridiculous hoarded wealth, and very little in the middle.
If you want to debate whether its okay to use AI or not with me, I’m not interested. It’s not about whether or not we should. We’ve gotten so far past that point, it’s scary. It’s how we move forward as a species. If I’m going to be able to talk intelligently about how to make a world where we all benefit instead of die off, I have to wrap my head around AI. I have to use it.
The one place I won’t use it, is to write my books. It can be my research assistant. It can spot errors like me putting a new moon on the wrong night… I never got more of an “email from an angry nerd” vibe from AI than when Google Gemini mansplained that error to me. And I know the vibe because I’ve exuded it now and then.
I believe that the road forward is where AI doesn’t do everything for us. It will free us to concentrate on what we love doing. For me that’s writing books. I don’t want to put my name on a book written by AI because what would be my reason for existing if existing was all I did?
So if you want to yell at me about my use of AI, your words will be intercepted and round-filed by AI. It will make sure I don’t even have to delete attempts to start arguments or pick fights. It’s not to avoid having to encounter thoughts that disagree with mine. It’s because after the first dozen arguments, they all became the same. It is not my duty to continue to mine this tapped-out vein of argument.
If you’re ready to accept AI is inevitable and want to discuss how we can move forward in a peaceful and universally prosperous way… the AI filter will keep a count of those and if there are enough, maybe we can have a virtual town hall where people of good-will can discuss honest solutions, but I’m done with trying to convince people, one at a time, that they’re having this argument 10 years too late.